- The Road to Two Degrees, Part Two: Are the experts being candid about our chances?
- Two-faced Exxon: the misinformation campaign against its own scientists
- Study drives a sixth nail into the global warming ‘pause’ myth
- Tracking the 2C Limit - October 2015
- 2015 SkS Weekly Digest #47
- 2015 SkS Weekly News Roundup #47
- So what's really happening in Antarctica?
- SBC Energy Institute Climate Factbook
- 2015 shatters the temperature record as global warming speeds back up
- Book review: Climate Change, What Everyone Needs to Know
- The Road to Two Degrees, Part One: Feasible Emissions Pathways, Burying our Carbon, and Bioenergy
- Exxon climate revelations are just part of a long history of science misinformation
- 2015 SkS Weekly Digest #46
- 2015 SkS Weekly News Roundup #46
- Video: Drought, Climate, Security, and Syria
- Why were the ancient oceans favorable to marine life when atmospheric carbon dioxide was higher than today?
- Lamar Smith, climate scientist witch hunter
- G R A P H E N E
- By rejecting Keystone, President Obama cements his climate legacy
- 2015 SkS Weekly Digest #45
- 2015 SkS Weekly News Roundup #45
- The thermometer needle and the damage done
- Scientists warned the US president about global warming 50 years ago today
- Q&A: Is Antarctica gaining or losing ice?
- Arbitrary focus on hurricane wind speed has birthed a new climate myth
- Homogenization of Temperature Data: An Assessment
- 2015 SkS Weekly Digest #44
- 2015 SkS Weekly News Roundup #44
- 2015: A Very Bad Year for the Global Warming Policy Foundation
- Newest Entry in Inside Climate News’ #ExxonKnew Story is a Doozy
ENSO Temperature Trends
NOAA estimates of the change in average annual global surface air temperature (1966–2015) show that much of the short-term variability in the upward temperature trend is produced by the El Niño/La Niña Southern Oscillation (ENSO), a 2–7 year climate pattern in the tropical Pacific. Average air temperature is affected by many different factors, including: anthropogenic (human-caused) global warming (AGW) that is mainly caused by CO2 emissions from burning fossil fuels; the 11-year solar sunspot cycle; sulfate aerosols from volcanic eruptions; and the periodic ENSO.
In this analysis, each year was classified as either an El Niño, La Niña, or ENSO-neutral year based on the average of 3 common ENSO indices. The years were then ranked and the top, middle, and bottom approximately one-third of the ranked years were classified as El Niño, neutral, and La Niña years, as described here. Years that were strongly influenced by the volcanic eruptions of El Chichón (1983–1985) and Mount Pinatubo (1992–1994) were excluded from the analysis due to the temporary cooling effect of volcanic aerosols.
First Frame: NOAA global surface temperature data show a clear increasing trend, but it is "noisy" because multiple influences are present in the data (AGW, ENSO, volcanoes, solar cycle).
Middle Frames: Each year is classified according to its ENSO index as either an El Niño year (red), La Niña year (blue), ENSO-neutral year (black), excluding volcanic years (orange triangles). Each category of year is shown with its linear temperature trend.
Final Frame: Linear trends are calculated for each category, with the result that after accounting for the variability attributed to ENSO (and removing the effect of volcanic eruptions), each category shows essentially the same underlying global warming trend of 0.15–0.17°C per decade. Short-term cyclical factors like ENSO and the solar cycle average to about zero net effect over time, and volcanic influences are temporary.
Climate contrarians sometimes claim that global warming has somehow magically stopped in recent years based on their "cherry picking" short time periods of reduced temperature increase. However, in reality there was a preponderance of El Niño events in the 1990s and a preponderance of La Niña events since 2000, where the former cause short-term surface warming and the latter cause short-term cooling. Accounting for the El Niño/La Niña influence clarifies that human-caused global warming continues unabated.
SkS Resources that use this Graphic
Printable Version | Back to Graphics by Skeptical Science
The Consensus Project Website
(free to republish)
THE DEBUNKING HANDBOOK
BOOK NOW AVAILABLE
The Scientific Guide to
Global Warming Skepticism